Letters: Opposition, intransigence and terrorism in the Middle East

You publish a letter that I find shocking (26 January), arguing that terrorism is a justified moral response to Israeli intransigence. I have spent long periods in Israel and the Palestinian territories, meeting leaders on both sides, and doing the sam… Continue reading


Letters: Opposition, intransigence and terrorism in the Middle East

You publish a letter that I find shocking (26 January), arguing that terrorism is a justified moral response to Israeli intransigence. I have spent long periods in Israel and the Palestinian territories, meeting leaders on both sides, and doing the same in Republican areas of Northern Ireland. My conclusion is that terrorism’s audience is a domestic political one; it is designed to make militant a home population and render it fertile to the political ambitions of one party. It cannot be that it holds to a practical aim when that requires the abolition of the state of Israel or “the removal of the British from Ireland”.

Terrorism prolongs conflict and postpones resolution, as well as wasting innocent lives. The rowing back from the bloodshed is hard. Meanwhile, there is in Israel an articulate and motivated peace lobby. Who could argue that terrorism has not empowered the political right in that country and entrenched its divisions, weakening the case of those who argue for a settlement? There is neither a “moral right” nor a practical argument for terrorism in the modern world.

Stephen Davis

Rodborough Common, Gloucestershire

• I have been a supporter of the Palestinian cause for many years, but I do not believe terrorism is justified. If suicide bombing is the only avenue available, then that is tolerable against military forces. Blowing yourself up outside falafel stands is most definitely not.

Kashif Sheikh

Huddersfield, West Yorkshire

• Various people have lined up to urge Ian McEwan not to accept the Jerusalem prize. It was such opposition that provoked Susan Sontag into attending. In her speech she attacked Israel for its policy of collective punishment, the demolition of homes and the building of settlements. People left the hall. Arthur Miller had his doubts, but accepted. In his recorded speech, he accused Israel of adopting a self-defeating policy. He was denounced by the newly elected ultra-Orthodox mayor. Good luck, Ian.

Christopher Bigsby

University of East Anglia

Ian McEwan (Letters, 26 January) cites Daniel Barenboim in his defence. The incredibly brave Barenboim has not only formed a wonderful, ethnically inclusive orchestra. He has repeatedly championed the rights of the Palestinians. When a while ago he received an award in the Israeli parliament building, he was insulted for his peace efforts by a minister. He responded with vigour and without apology. Can we expect similar outspokenness from McEwan?

Gerald Kaufman MP

Lab, Manchester Gorton

• How sad that on Holocaust Memorial Day a British writer should be told not to accept a prize from his Jewish admirers in Israel.

Denis MacShane MP

Lab, Rotherham

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2011 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Only authentic leaders can deliver a Middle East peace | Seumas Milne

This week’s leaks have exposed the dangerous folly of US and British attempts to control and divide the PalestiniansIt’s a tragedy for the Palestinian people that at a time when their cause is the focus of greater global popular support than ever in th… Continue reading


Only authentic leaders can deliver a Middle East peace | Seumas Milne

This week’s leaks have exposed the dangerous folly of US and British attempts to control and divide the PalestiniansIt’s a tragedy for the Palestinian people that at a time when their cause is the focus of greater global popular support than ever in th… Continue reading


Palestine papers: Erekat asks US, UK and France for help to find leaker

Senior Palestinian negotiator says he wants ex-British spy, US journalist and French national to appear before inquiryA senior Palestinian official today said he has asked the US, Britain and France to help bring three of their nationals for questionin… Continue reading


Palestine papers: Erekat asks US, UK and France for help to find leaker

Senior Palestinian negotiator says he wants ex-British spy, US journalist and French national to appear before inquiryA senior Palestinian official today said he has asked the US, Britain and France to help bring three of their nationals for questionin… Continue reading


Guardian Focus podcast: The Palestine Papers

The spotlight has fallen on the stalled – some day dead – Middle East peace process this week as thousands of pages of secret material were shared with the Guardian by al-Jazeera TV.Ian Black, the Guardian’s Middle East editor, unpacks the week’s relea… Continue reading


Guardian Focus podcast: The Palestine Papers

The spotlight has fallen on the stalled – some day dead – Middle East peace process this week as thousands of pages of secret material were shared with the Guardian by al-Jazeera TV.Ian Black, the Guardian’s Middle East editor, unpacks the week’s relea… Continue reading


PA’s foreknowledge of the Gaza war?

Did the PA know about the Gaza war in advance? That’s a question raised by several exchanges in The Palestine Papers. Continue reading


PA’s foreknowledge of the Gaza war?

Did the PA know about the Gaza war in advance? That’s a question raised by several exchanges in The Palestine Papers. Continue reading


We Are Change Windsor’s Facebook Wall 2011-01-27 07:56:20

French PM vows to fight insane food prices | The Coming Economic Depression 2010www.thecomingdepression.net“We want regulation of primary commodity financial markets,” Sarkozy said in a speech in Paris overnight. “How can you explain that we regu… Continue reading


Palestine papers: Gaza report stalled by Palestinian Authority at request of US – video

Footage from al-Jazeera on the leaked Palestine Papers describes how the US influenced Palestinian negotiators, as anger over the leaks grows in Hamas-contolled Gaza Continue reading


Gaza war report was stalled by Palestinian Authority on US request

Papers reveal PA held up Goldstone report from UN security council and suggest Abbas was warned of 2008 invasionPalestinian Authority leaders co-operated with US officials in a bid to postpone the reference of the Goldstone report into war crimes in Ga… Continue reading


Palestine papers: Gaza report stalled by Palestinian Authority at request of US – video

Footage from al-Jazeera on the leaked Palestine Papers describes how the US influenced Palestinian negotiators, as anger over the leaks grows in Hamas-contolled Gaza Continue reading


Gaza war report was stalled by Palestinian Authority on US request

Papers reveal PA held up Goldstone report from UN security council and suggest Abbas was warned of 2008 invasionPalestinian Authority leaders co-operated with US officials in a bid to postpone the reference of the Goldstone report into war crimes in Ga… Continue reading